Friday, Sept. 30
One of the best parts of my day is attending Middle School athletic contests. Win or lose, I relish the fact that any Middle Schooler who wants to be on a team and compete has the opportunity to do so. This no-cut approach to sports fosters a sense of fun, challenge, and engagement for our students. Some students discover a passion for a new sport while others enjoy being with their peers outside of the classroom walls. Many of our students play several sports throughout the year, affording them multiple opportunities to develop friendships and athletic skills that keep them happy, fresh, and engaged.
As a teenager, I loved playing a wide-variety of sports, knowing that I had numerous opportunities to be with my friends in a variety of different athletic contexts. I played football for one season (with minimal success), developed a life-long love for competitive swimming, and grew to love the game of lacrosse. I was able to swim and play lacrosse at the collegiate level, but knew that (1) I would never become an elite athlete and (2) playing several sports kept me happy and healthy. When I read Jessica Grosse’s New York Times opinion article, “How Money is Ruining Youth Sports,” I was again reminded of the benefits of being on an athletic team, especially during adolescence. Grosse notes that, for herself, being on an athletic team “always felt like a respite from adolescent drama, and it provided structure and solace on even the worst days. Being part of a team taught me a lot of lessons, not least of which that showing up on time and ready to play has tangible benefits, no matter what happens in the game.”
Providing adolescents with the chance to reap these types of “tangible benefits” is vitally important from both a social and physical perspective. In our Middle School, we give students the chance to play on teams where the importance is focused more on having fun and working with others rather than on a winning-at-all-costs attitude. I fondly recall a conversation I had with an eighth grade boy who had just finished his basketball season. When I asked him how his season went, he replied that, even though he had been a member of the C-Team and had only scored two points all season, he loved being a part of his team. At the end of our conversation, he shared with me that he was going to play lacrosse in the spring, even though he had never held a lacrosse stick in his hands. From my perspective, this is what sports should be about, especially at the Middle School level of play.
I am well aware of the fact that our approach to sports at Seven Hills often runs counter to what is actually going on in our society when it comes to youth sports. More and more kids are specializing in sports at younger and younger ages, often in the belief that they will be able to garner the attention of college coaches, in the hopes of paving the way to an all-expense paid college experience. In her article, Grosse comments that one of the biggest drivers that has fueled this specialization on one sport has been, sadly, money: “the problem is systemic. At its base, over the past several decades, ‘kids’ sports stopped being for kids…There are fewer low-cost options, the time parents are spending on sports has ratcheted up and kids from lower-income families have less access to play. Instead, youth sports are about making adults money and fueling what some economists call the ‘rug rat race’ — middle class and upper middle class competition to get kids into colleges and secure their futures.” And while there are kids whose specialization does pay off (e.g. scholarships, sponsorships, etc.), the literal costs that parents spend on this type of “success” is often exorbitant and short lived (e.g. travel team membership fees, travel costs, etc.). Grosse cites the research that came out of the Family Sports Lab at Utah State: “They discovered that the more parents spend on their kids’ sports, the less the kid enjoys it and the more pressure they feel.”
While specialization in one sport can be beneficial, I do worry about the long-term effects of this type of approach to sports. What happens to a child who, after years and years of practice and competition, fails to win that elusive scholarship or recognition? Often, the child ends up leaving the sport. For me, this is the real tragedy in pursuing such intense specialization in athletics. Sports should be about enjoyment and fun. Sports should be about the development of physical skills as much as it should be about the development of social and emotional skills. Having coached Middle and Upper School students at a variety of schools and in many sports for the past 30 years, I know that those students who played multiple sports gained so much from these varied experiences. And when I see that eighth grade boy who scored a grand total of two points on the C-Team walking the halls as a 12th grader today, I know for certain that he will remember those two points were just as important as the fact that he is now one of the stars of our school’s lacrosse team.
Friday, Sept. 23
This week’s Message is meant to detail some of the finer points of the Middle School CARES framework that I have been writing about in my previous Messages from the Middle. As you may recall, this framework is intended to establish the types of social and emotional behaviors that serve to create a Middle School where all members (students and faculty) thrive as a cohesive community, focused on positive growth and learning. Cultivating Accountability, Respect, Empathy, and Safety is central in allowing all of us to take care of ourselves, others, and our community.
Central to the Middle School CARES framework is the core belief that students need to be intentionally taught what positive expected behaviors look like in a variety of campus locations. Just as students don’t naturally know the intricacies of meiosis and mitosis, we, as adults, bear the important responsibility in working with our students so that they understand and embrace these behaviors.
Traditionally, schools have not often spent much time in the arena of behavioral education, in the belief that “rules” can simply be followed and real learning can easily take place inside the classroom. Proponents of this approach to “teaching” either assume that students innately “know the rules” and can “follow” them or that behavioral transgressions can simply be addressed when they occur with punishments and consequences, allowing students to then return to the task of learning. Many of us, as adults, may have well experienced this type of “learning” when we were in Junior High/Middle School. This top-down style of behavioral management often does little more than create blind or confused compliance while depriving students of a sense of agency, buy-in, and understanding of what creates a comfortable and inclusive community where all voices, including those of the students, can be heard.
For the past three weeks, our faculty and students have been working together to honestly discuss and agree upon the types of expected behaviors that are appropriate in a variety of places. These discussions, that worked to include the ideas and thoughts of students, resulted in agreed-upon behaviors that should be expected by all members of our community. Once these expected behaviors had been clearly identified, students and faculty are now in the process of practicing and re-learning these behaviors, knowing that it takes repetition and compassionate support to empower students with the understanding that they have the ability to manage their behaviors in ways that best support caring for themselves, others, and their community.
Students, just like adults, need to not only know what is expected from them, but they also need to know what happens when unexpected behaviors occur that go against the norms of their community. Rather than meeting an unexpected behavior with an immediate and arbitrary punishment, the Middle School CARES framework approaches unexpected behaviors with an understood and appropriate range of tiered responses. More often than not, our response to unexpected behaviors resembles the following tiered approach:
- A discussion between the teacher and the student about the unexpected behavior
- A teacher-determined consequence that is logical and appropriate to the
unexpected behavior
- A lunch detention where the student has the chance to positively reflect on their
behavior
- Referral to the Student CARES Team
Most often, a simple discussion with an adult serves to help students understand and appropriately adjust their behaviors. The range of tiered responses increases in an attempt to provide students with greater support that will help them readjust their behaviors. If a student is truly struggling with any of our community’s expected behaviors, the Student CARES Team, made up of a variety of teachers and administrators, serves to meet and support students in understanding what they need in terms of support to better embrace and own behaviors with which they may be struggling.
Obviously there may be types of unexpected behaviors in our Middle School community that our Middle School CARES framework simply isn’t designed to handle. Issues such as the use of violence, drugs, weapons, certain types of bullying, etc. almost always require the immediate attention of administrators who can best address these more extreme behaviors and determine the most logical consequence.
Born out of the belief that students deserve compassionate support and possess the ability to be positive members of our community, the Middle School CARES framework strives to teach all members of our Middle School what behaviors can best serve them at this important stage in their development. Why?…because Middle School CARES!
Friday, Sept. 16
In last week’s Middle School Blast, I shared with our community the creation of a framework intended to establish the types of social and emotional behaviors that will create a community of learners where students, as well as faculty, thrive. Known as Middle School CARES, this framework captures the true intent of what we are striving to do within our community: Cultivating Accountability, Respect, Empathy, and Safety. As educators, it is incumbent upon us to provide a clear understanding of the behavioral expectations in our school, as these expectations are centrally supportive to the three core beliefs of our Middle School community and culture:
Care of Yourself
Care of Others
Care of Our Community.
While it is important to research and determine what expected behaviors might best serve a student’s overall social, emotional, and academic development, it is a challenge to create a framework that fosters a sense of student buy-in and agreement when it comes to establishing “rules” that we, as adults, want our students to “follow.” In their book, “Better Than Carrots and Sticks,” authors Smith, Fisher, and Frey cite the all-too-common approach that schools have long-held when it comes to handling student discipline: “It’s far too common in schools for educators to wait for discipline problems to emerge and then handle them on a case-by-case basis. Such an approach leaves adults exhausted and children with limited skills development.” Having worked in eight independent schools during the course of my educational career, I have often witnessed the same approach in teaching the social and emotional development of students that is “often poorly articulated in schools — relegated to an assembly and a few accompanying lessons.” And the traditional tools for dealing with student behavioral issues has, sadly, often been rooted in approaches that don’t work over time and can occasionally be antithetical to what schools are supposed to be doing: teaching. “Reward and consequences, shame and humiliation…do not result in lasting change, much less a productive learning environment.”
The work that was performed this past summer in the creation of the Middle School CARES framework resulted in the clear understanding that students need to be a part of the process in identifying and understanding the behavioral expectations that result in creating a community where they can thrive. Knowing that the three core beliefs of our Middle School — Care of Yourself, Care of Others, and Care of Our Community — are central to a healthy community, we have worked with our students during these opening three weeks of school to create a clear understanding of what expected behaviors look like for each of these beliefs:
Care of Yourself
Ensuring that a student has what they need to be a successful member of our Middle School is vital. This means that as adults, we are helping students learn to take responsibility for their own needs (e.g., physical, emotional, academic, social, etc.) so that they can succeed in the many areas of their lives in Middle School. In the classroom, a student needs to know what is needed to be successful and then exhibit behaviors that best take care of themselves in this type of setting. Other settings will necessarily determine what a student needs to do in order to take care of themselves as well. When students are eating lunch, gathered for large group meetings and assemblies, on the stage, or on the playing field, they need to be aware of what is needed to best take care of themselves. Simply put, Care of Yourself means understanding what will allow a student to be personally successful in all areas of life in our Middle School community.
Care of Others
Helping students understand the responsibility they have to care for others serves to develop the empathy needed for a caring and compassionate community that best supports the needs of all its members. This means that it is a student’s responsibility to learn, with our adult guidance, what types of behaviors are helpful and can best take care of the needs of others in a positive and supportive manner. Learning how to take care of others can mean showing kindness to another student and knowing what types of comments or actions would be helpful for others. It can also mean knowing how and when to stand up for others who need the support and care of others. Whether it is in the classroom, the hallway, or the cafeteria, Care of Others means understanding that this type of care extends beyond one’s own needs and is intimately connected to the overall health of our Middle School community.
Care of Our Community
Understanding that each and every member of the Middle School plays an integral role in creating and supporting a healthy and happy community, it is appropriate that all students develop and understand their sense of ownership and the role they play in maintaining the positive academic, social, and emotional behaviors that define our community. Whether through simple and easy actions like picking up after each other or respecting school property, Care of Our Community relies on a sense of communal responsibility that asks each member to act in appropriate ways at all times.
Knowing that it takes time for students to “buy-in,” learn, and embrace these expected behaviors, we are still in the early stages of teaching, modeling, and re-teaching these expected behaviors. Research shows that, while it takes time for expected behaviors to become routinized, the most important part of any approach to student discipline is the relationship students have with their teachers…because Middle School CARES.
Friday, Sept. 9
Many of us have memories (most probably bad ones) when we hear the phrase “school discipline.” When I hear this phrase, I immediately go back to my second grade year at Lincoln Elementary School in New Britain, Connecticut. For whatever reason, my teacher, Mrs. Fuecco, had a strange obsession with students “tattling” on each other during class time. Her solution to address this problem? If you “tattled” on another student, you had to wear a red paper cut-out “Tattle Tail” that was pinned to the offending student’s backside (a.k.a. one’s butt) for the remainder of the day. To add insult to injury, the following words were written in bold black magic marker in a horizontal manner on the tail: “I’M A LITTLE TATTLE TALE.” Needless to say, Mrs. Fuecco’s approach to “discipline” did little more than create shame and embarrassment in her students. At the same time, it compelled those students who had a budding understanding of curse words that started with the letter “F” to create a song that wasn’t all that flattering to Mrs. Fuecco herself. If you want me to sing a verse of the “Mrs. Fuecco Song,” just find me and I will treat your ears to this wonderful little ditty.
For centuries, schools have struggled to create a “disciplinary system” that effectively addresses the types of behaviors that help students truly succeed. Often, schools develop and rely on a system of rewards and punishments that only result in short-term change and compliance, if little else. Alfie Kohn, well-known author and lecturer in the areas of education, parenting, and human behavior, notes that “scores of studies have confirmed that rewards tend to lead people to lose interest in whatever they had to do to snag them. This principle has been replicated with many different populations (across genders, ages, and nationalities) and with a variety of tasks as well as different kinds of inducements (money, A’s, food, and praise, to name four).” In their book, “Better Than Carrots and Sticks”, authors Dominique Smith, Douglas Fisher, and Nancy Frey cite that “punishments rely on our ability as adults to leverage an unequal power relationship over children; it puts students in their places by reminding them who’s really in charge.” While rewards and punishments might create temporary changes when it comes to student behavior, the truth in these approaches is simple: rewards and punishments don’t work and don’t teach students how to truly behave. When I had to walk around Lincoln School for a day with a red tail affixed to my rear-end, I only became more careful and secretive with tattling on others, and quickly learned the words to the “Mrs. Fuecco Song.”
For a school-based disciplinary system to be truly effective, one only needs to understand the definition of the root word from which “disciplinary” derives — disciple: one who follows the beliefs of a leader or school of thought and spreads these beliefs to others. Simply put, a disciplinary system strives to teach students how to behave. Just as we don’t leave the acquisition of certain academic skills to chance, we must, in a similar manner, “engage in explicit, systematic, and intentional instruction” when it comes to ensuring that our students “progress socially and emotionally” as “Better Than Carrots and Sticks” said. And when our students are able to bring a sense of purpose, understanding, and relevance to the expected behaviors that will positively augment their overall experience in school, a true community of learners emerges.
As a Middle School, we have recently taken a very close look at how we want to establish the types of social and emotional behaviors that will create a community of learners where students, as well as faculty, thrive. This past summer, an enormous amount of work went into the creation of a framework that we are currently introducing to our students, called Middle School CARES. The acronym itself, CARES, captures the true intent of what we are striving to do: Cultivating Accountability, Respect, Empathy, and Safety. The true essence and purpose of the CARES framework can be understood in the intentional “Statement of Purpose & Goals” that was developed this past summer:
At the Seven Hills Middle School, we seek to best support our students’ behavioral, academic, social, emotional, and mental health. To promote student success in these areas, our Middle School provides a safe learning space where students feel valued and understood, develop meaningful and positive relationships with their teachers, and experience a deep sense of belonging.
The main goal of Middle School CARES is to improve students’ social emotional competence, academic success, behavioral expectations, and our overall school climate. This goal also serves to improve teacher health and wellbeing by creating positive, reliable, fair, and safe learning environments where everyone thrives.
As educators, we must provide a clear understanding of the behavioral expectations in our school, as these expectations are centrally supportive to the three core beliefs of our Middle School community and culture:
Care of Yourself
Care of Others
Care of Our Community
When students take care of themselves, their classmates, and their school community, we can ensure that we are striving to support their best selves at all times.
In the coming weeks, I will be outlining the specific components of the CARES framework that we have introduced to our students during these opening weeks of school. One thing I can assure you is that you won’t find any red paper cut-out “I’M A LITTLE TATTLE TALE” accessorizing a student’s outfit for the day… Stay tuned!
Friday, Sept. 2
Welcome to the 2022-23 school year! I hope that these first two weeks have gone well for you and your Middle Schooler. Each week in the Middle School Blast, I attempt to gather my thoughts around an important topic or idea that directly relates to the lives of our Middle School students. Hopefully, my “Message from the Middle” musings will prove helpful or informative as we all strive to raise happy and healthy adolescents. Please feel free to share with me your thoughts and reactions, knowing that we are all in this together!
Driving to school this morning, I was listening to one of my favorite podcasts, “The Daily,” hosted by New York Times journalist Michael Barbaro. This morning’s podcast brought me to a place I have come to accept as part of my day-to-day reality in working with young adolescents; worrying about their mental health. Titled “Inside the Adolescent Mental Health Crisis,” this podcast illuminated what is now being called a public mental health emergency. In 2021, Dr. Vivek Murthy, the U.S. Surgeon General, authored a 53-page report, “Protecting Youth Mental Health,” in which he states, “But the challenges today’s generation of young people face are unprecedented and uniquely hard to navigate. And the effect these challenges have had on their mental health is devastating.” And while we, as a Middle School, take the mental health of our students seriously and have created programs and curriculum to address many of these issues, I am still struck by the word that Dr. Murthy uses to underscore how he feels about the state of our children’s mental health: devastating.
When one attempts to digest the data that supports Dr. Murthy’s assessment of the state of our children’s mental health, the reality is shocking. In Matt Richtel’s April 23, 2022 New York Times article “It’s Life or Death: The Mental Health Crisis Among U.S. Teens,” he cites some sobering statistics: “In 2019, 13 percent of adolescents reported having a major depressive episode, a 60 percent increase from 2007. Emergency room visits by children and adolescents in that period also rose sharply for anxiety, mood disorders, and self-harm. And for people ages 10 to 24, suicide rates, stable from 2000 to 2007, leaped nearly 60 percent by 2018, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.” Like any curious individual, I find myself searching for answers to the frightening rise in these numbers. How and why is this happening?
While it was only two and half years ago that the outbreak of COVID-19 changed our world, I don’t feel that this pandemic is solely responsible for the state of our children’s mental health. Even though the spreading use of cell phones and ready access to social media has had profoundly negative effects on our children’s mental health, I don’t know if this growth in technology is solely to blame as well. What is it that has truly changed in the lives of our children? It was in listening to “The Daily” podcast that I gained a bit more understanding as to the nature of what has changed for our children.
There was a time in our not-too-distant past that the public health risks adolescents were exposed to were more external in nature. Thirty and forty years ago, binge drinking, drunk driving, cigarette use, experimentation with drugs, and sexual activity were fairly popular externalized risks that were often experienced with one’s peers in more group-centered activities. However, when you look at the rate of incidence of these same activities from 30 years ago to today, things have drastically changed, albeit, for the better. In 1990, 50 percent of teenagers reported having had sex at least once; now that figure is 38 percent. In 2019, 4 percent of high schoolers reported smoking a cigarette in the last 30 days, down from 26.5 percent in 1997. Along with this, alcohol use has hit 30-year lows.
With the drops in these types of public health risks, there has also been a rise in the more internalized risks that adolescents are now facing, such as anxiety, depression, mood disorders, and stress. After listening to “The Daily” podcast and reading Matt Richtel’s NYT article, it appears to me that there is a common denominator that underlies many of the mental health risks our children are now facing: loneliness. Richtel states that “Aarise in loneliness is a key factor… Recent studies have shown that teenagers in the United States and worldwide increasingly report feeling lonely, even in a period when their internet use has exploded.” It’s no wonder that, when a 13-year-old checks his social media feed and sees pictures of his classmates having fun without him, he feels more isolated, disconnected, and depressed about his own sense of self. It’s also no wonder when a 12-year-old girl refuses to go to school, fearing the ridicule she may face as a result of an embarrassing picture her “friend” had posted without her permission.
While I don’t have any immediate answers or quick-fixes to the mental health challenges that our children are now facing, I feel more strongly than ever that we, as adults, have to find authentic ways to connect with our children and to connect our children with the world outside their bedrooms. It is my sincere hope that our Seven Hills Middle School can be just that sort of community that serves to facilitate relationships that empower students to feel valued and respected. Thankfully, we have a robust array of mental health resources at Seven Hills that can help our children successfully navigate these challenging years in their lives.